# PVUGC Security Analysis - Updated Index

**Report Date:** 2025-10-07
**Report Version:** 2.0 (Updated)
**Protocol:** PVUGC (Publicly Verifiable Universal General Computation)
**Analyzed Document:** PVUGC-2025-10-20.md §1 Introduction (v2 with Multi-CRS AND-ing)
**Total Flaws Identified:** 10

---

## Quick Reference Table

| Code | Title | Severity | Status | Change from v1.0 | File |
|------|-------|----------|--------|------------------|------|
| **PVUGC-001** | GT-XPDH Assumption Non-Standard | 🔴 **Critical** | 🔓 Open | Mitigated by Multi-CRS | [PVUGC-001-gt-xpdh-assumption.md](PVUGC-001-gt-xpdh-assumption) |
| **PVUGC-002** | Multi-CRS AND-ing Missing | 🔴 Critical → N/A | ✅ Resolved | **Now mandatory** | [PVUGC-002-multi-crs-anding.md](PVUGC-002-multi-crs-anding) |
| **PVUGC-003** | Independence Property Needs Proof | 🔴 **Critical** | 🔧 Improved | MUST clause added | [PVUGC-003-independence-property.md](PVUGC-003-independence-property) |
| **PVUGC-004** | PoCE-B Decapper-Local | 🟠 **High** | 🔓 Open | Publication SHOULD added | [PVUGC-004-poce-soundness.md](PVUGC-004-poce-soundness) |
| **PVUGC-005** | Context Binding Incomplete | 🟡 **Medium** | 🔧 Improved | Layered hash structure | [PVUGC-005-context-binding.md](PVUGC-005-context-binding) |
| **PVUGC-006** | Degenerate Value Guards | 🟠 High → N/A | ✅ Resolved | Explicit checks added | [PVUGC-006-degenerate-values.md](PVUGC-006-degenerate-values) |
| **PVUGC-007** | Timing/Race Conditions | 🟡 **Medium** | 🔓 Open | Implementation-dependent | [PVUGC-007-timing-race-conditions.md](PVUGC-007-timing-race-conditions) |
| **PVUGC-008** | MuSig2 Compartmentalization | 🟡 **Medium** | 🔧 Improved | Clarified (enforcement TBD) | [PVUGC-008-musig2-compartmentalization.md](PVUGC-008-musig2-compartmentalization) |
| **PVUGC-009** | DEM Profile Multiplicity | 🟠 High → N/A | ✅ Resolved | Single mandatory DEM | [PVUGC-009-dem-profile.md](PVUGC-009-dem-profile) |
| **PVUGC-010** | CRS Validation Insufficient | 🟢 Low → N/A | ✅ Resolved | Binding + digest pinning | [PVUGC-010-crs-validation.md](PVUGC-010-crs-validation) |

---

## Summary by Status

| Status | Count | Codes |
|--------|-------|-------|
| ✅ **Resolved** | 4 | PVUGC-002, PVUGC-006, PVUGC-009, PVUGC-010 |
| 🔧 **Improved** | 3 | PVUGC-003, PVUGC-005, PVUGC-008 |
| 🔓 **Open** | 3 | PVUGC-001, PVUGC-004, PVUGC-007 |
| **Total** | **10** | |

---

## Summary by Severity (v2.0)

| Severity | Count (Active) | Codes |
|----------|----------------|-------|
| 🔴 **Critical** | 2 | PVUGC-001 (open), PVUGC-003 (improved) |
| 🟠 **High** | 1 | PVUGC-004 (open) |
| 🟡 **Medium** | 3 | PVUGC-005 (improved), PVUGC-007 (open), PVUGC-008 (improved) |
| 🟢 **Low** | 0 | *(PVUGC-010 resolved)* |
| **Total Active** | **6** | |

**Note:** 4 flaws resolved in v2.0 (PVUGC-002, PVUGC-006, PVUGC-009, PVUGC-010)

---

## Version Comparison

| Metric | v1.0 (Preliminary) | v2.0 (Updated) | Change |
|--------|-------------------|----------------|--------|
| **Total Flaws** | 10 | 10 | → (re-numbered) |
| 🔴 Critical | 3 | 2 active + 1 resolved | ⬇️ **-1** |
| 🟠 High | 3 | 1 active + 2 resolved | ⬇️ **-2** |
| 🟡 Medium | 2 | 3 active | ⬆️ **+1** |
| 🟢 Low | 2 | 0 active + 1 resolved | ⬇️ **-1** |
| **Resolved** | 0 | 4 | ✅ **+4** |
| **Improved** | 0 | 3 | 🔧 **+3** |

---

## Navigation

- **[README.md](README)** - Executive summary, major improvements, recommendations
- **00-INDEX.md** - This file (quick reference with status tracking)
- **Individual flaw reports** - Click file links in table above

---

## Status Legend

- ✅ **Resolved** - Issue fully addressed in v2.0 specification
- 🔧 **Improved** - Partial mitigation implemented, further work needed
- 🔓 **Open** - Issue remains, may have mitigation layers
- 🔍 **Investigating** - Analysis in progress (not used in v2.0)
- ❌ **Disputed** - Not considered a valid flaw (not used in v2.0)

---

## Priority Actions (Updated for v2.0)

### Phase 1: Critical Path to Mainnet (2-3 months)

**Critical Issues:**
1. **PVUGC-001** 🔴 Open: Engage pairing cryptography experts for formal cryptanalysis of GT-XPDH assumption
2. **PVUGC-003** 🔴 Improved: Formalize setup ceremony and prove independence property for BLS12-381

**High Priority:**
3. **PVUGC-004** 🟠 Open: Consider making PoCE-B publicly verifiable or add on-chain penalty mechanisms

**Implementation Requirements:**
- [ ] Reference implementation (Rust/C++) with all MUST clauses enforced
- [ ] Comprehensive test suite (edge cases, malicious scenarios)
- [ ] CRS generation ceremony (≥2 independent binding CRS transcripts)

### Phase 2: External Validation (3-6 months)

**Medium Priority (Improved):**
4. **PVUGC-005** 🟡 Improved: Verify layered hash structure prevents all replay scenarios
5. **PVUGC-008** 🟡 Improved: Implement and test MuSig2 compartmentalization enforcement

**Medium Priority (Open):**
6. **PVUGC-007** 🟡 Open: Add explicit timeouts, constant-time implementation, phase transitions

**External Review:**
- [ ] External security audit by pairing-crypto specialists
- [ ] Public review period with academic cryptographers
- [ ] Bug bounty program (testnet deployment)

### Phase 3: Production Deployment (6-12 months)

**Resolved (Verification Required):**
- **PVUGC-002** ✅: Verify Multi-CRS AND-ing implementation (KDF construction, separate masks)
- **PVUGC-006** ✅: Verify degenerate value checks (G_G16 ≠ 1, subgroup membership)
- **PVUGC-009** ✅: Verify production DEM (Poseidon2-based, BLS12-381)
- **PVUGC-010** ✅: Verify CRS validation (binding requirement, digest pinning)

---

## Major Improvements in v2.0

### ✅ Resolved Flaws (4)

1. **PVUGC-002**: Multi-CRS AND-ing now **MUST** (production profile §89-91)
   - Minimum 2 independently generated binding GS-CRS transcripts
   - Separate mask sets per CRS with logical AND verification
   - Exponentially hardens GT-XPDH assumption

2. **PVUGC-006**: Degenerate value checks now explicit
   - Hard limit: m₁ + m₂ ≤ 96 pairings
   - Abort if G_G16 = 1 or in proper subgroup
   - PoCE MUST assert G_G16 ≠ 1

3. **PVUGC-009**: Single mandatory DEM profile
   - **MUST**: DEM_PROFILE = "PVUGC/DEM-P2-v1" (Poseidon2-based)
   - Eliminates interoperability vulnerabilities

4. **PVUGC-010**: CRS validation improved
   - **MUST**: GS CRS must be binding
   - Both CRS digests pinned in `GS_instance_digest` and `header_meta`
   - **SHOULD**: CRS generated via publicly auditable ceremony

### 🔧 Improved Flaws (3)

1. **PVUGC-003**: Independence property strengthened
   - Explicit MUST clause for span independence
   - Enhanced domain separation requirements
   - **Still needs**: Formal proof for BLS12-381

2. **PVUGC-005**: Context binding enhanced
   - Layered hash structure with explicit domain tags
   - SHA-256 for byte-level, Poseidon2 for in-circuit
   - **Still needs**: Cross-context replay testing

3. **PVUGC-008**: MuSig2 compartmentalization clarified
   - Explicit MUST clause for uniqueness
   - Normative domain tags specified
   - **Still needs**: Runtime enforcement mechanism

---

## Overall Assessment

**Status:** 🟡 **APPROACHING PRODUCTION READINESS**

The protocol has made **substantial progress** with:
- ✅ 4 flaws fully resolved
- 🔧 3 flaws significantly improved
- 🔓 3 flaws open (with mitigation strategies)

**Remaining Critical Work:**
1. Formal cryptanalysis of GT-XPDH assumption (or reduction to standard assumptions)
2. Formal proof of G_G16 independence from bases
3. Reference implementation with all security checks
4. External security audit by pairing-crypto specialists

**Timeline to Mainnet:** 6-12 months (assuming Phase 1-3 completion)

---

**Last Updated:** 2025-10-07
**Report Version:** 2.0 (Updated Analysis)
**Previous Version:** v1.0 (Preliminary, 2025-10-07)